A G20 triangular model of economic cooperation

The approaching G20 summit is set to focus on such themes as lowering regulatory burdens, building affordable and secure energy supply chains, and advancing new technologies and innovations (see: https://g20.org). While all these focus themes are very much in need of being addressed, the more fundamental problem afflicting the global economy is the low degree of inclusivity of global platforms such as the G20 itself as well as the lack of connectivity across the various engagement groups and disparate/ad hoc economic initiatives of the international community. If the inclusivity issue within the G20 were to be duly addressed, this international platform could provide a basis for building connectivity linkages across all the main levels of global governance – something that would go a long way to raising the effectiveness of G20 anti-crisis stimuli and its key economic initiatives in the sphere of infrastructural development and economic policy coordination.

Regarding the issue of G20 inclusivity, the expansion of the G20 membership to include the African Union has not gone far enough in addressing the legitimacy deficit of this global platform – the current status of regional organizations/integration arrangements such as the AU appears to be largely symbolic, without a G20 presidency mandate and thus far still devoid of an ambitious agenda. Indeed, without other major regional blocs from the Global South, there is insufficient scope for a full-scale bloc-to-bloc economic diplomacy for the current G20 regional members. And while the vast majority of global GDP is within the club’s membership and despite the many outreach initiatives undertaken by the G20 over nearly several decades, the majority of the country members of the international community are not duly engaged by the G20, rendering it still largely a gargantuan club with high national ambitions and limited global results.

Hence, rather than adding one by one new members to the G20 – a platform that already has more than 20 members – there may be a case for creating a parallel track in the form of a separate engagement group within the G20 that includes the main regional integration arrangements and thus expands the outreach of the platform to the majority of the members of the global economy. As we argued before, a regional R20 within the G20 would benefit global governance not just through greater inclusivity, but a greater engagement and integration of regional institutions into global economic initiatives, including the G20 anti-crisis stimuli. In this respect, an R20 platform could bring together not only the regional integration arrangements, but also their development institutions, such as regional financing arrangements (RFAs) and regional development banks.

Admittedly, the G20 despite its many difficulties is not completely devoid of change and in the past several years new engagement groups have emerged such as the Oceans 20 that expands the opportunities of building cooperation in the world’s Blue Economy segment. In fact the Oceans 20 may prove to be a crucial platform for bringing together regional organizations and partnerships, but rather than the standard inland RTAs they may connect oceanic platforms such as APEC and IORA. This in turn further improves the prospects of bringing in more regionalism and more regional arrangements into the G20 and the R20 could serve as a critical complement to the O20 oceanic platforms in the form of RTA regional arrangements in building inland-to-maritime connectivity networks. The resulting configuration of engagement groups enables the G20 platform to reach out to all the main layers of global governance includes:

The umbrella: G20: global platform/nation states;

  • R20: regional organizations and regional integration groups (inland)
  • O20: regional platforms (oceanic/maritime)
  • U20: sub-regional and municipal bodies

In effect, a triangular model along the R20-U20-O20 chain provides for connectivity between in-land regional integration arrangements and oceanic cooperative platforms (supra-national formations in both cases) that is intermediated by a sub-national platform of coastal regions and municipalities within the broader framework of G20 that is composed largely by nation-state members. All levels of global governance are brought together in the service of building new communication lines across the entire possibility set of sub-national, national and supra-national governance levels.

The role of the R20 within the G20 triangular model has to do with greater connectivity of inland and landlocked regions of the global economy to coastal regions and oceanic/maritime routes. In fact, thus far there are no landlocked country members in the G20 (excluding the effects of AU and EU membership), which significantly limits the involvement of such regions in G20 policy undertakings. Within the triad of R20, O20 and U20, the Urban 20 may play a crucial connectivity role between the regional integration platforms and oceanic partnerships. This is particularly the case with the urban centers that serve as key ports connecting maritime routes and inland logistics – for this track to be advanced the U20 engagement group could create a dedicated platform/cluster of port cities that would also work closely together with the C40 Cities platform.

One of the most promising connectivity tracks between the O20 and the potential R20 platform within the G20 would be a system of bi-oceanic corridors that could significantly reduce the dependency of the global economy on a limited number of choke-points. The operation of such a system of bi-oceanic corridors that are based on the transportation logistics through both coastal and inland regions could be significantly reinforced via coordination and rule harmonization across the respective regional integration arrangements and oceanic/coastal partnerships. A related theme of O20-R20 synergy could be joint work on building resilient supply chains as well as continuous environmental protection and monitoring across inland and maritime regions of the world economy.

Perhaps most importantly, the R20-U20-O20 model could open the path to a whole new set of international partnerships and alliances, which in turn would significantly expand the possibilities of environmental and economic diplomacy. In particular, hybrid alliances involving RTAs and oceanic platforms could be facilitated via such a triangular G20 model: for example ASEAN could work together with APEC and IORA in bringing both oceanic platforms closer in terms of their capability to support maritime connectivity and environmental policy coordination. ZOPACAS in the South Atlantic could work together with the AfCFTA and Mercosur in building greater connectivity across the two Global South regional blocs. Several oceanic platforms could coordinate greater economic cooperation with a given regional integration bloc thus advancing continental integration (ZOPACAS and IORA working for example with AfCFTA) and conversely, several regional integration platforms could be connected and cooperate around a given oceanic platform (IORA with respect to BIMSTEC and ASEAN). The U20 networks of port centers could build linkages with both R20 and O20 platforms to advance their position as key connectivity nodes between inland and maritime regions.

Overall, rather than being a platform for ever new rounds of stand-offs and disputes among member nation states, the G20 through its engagement groups and the triangular model could evolve into a flexible platform that reaches out to the vast majority of the global community and to all of the main levels of global governance – from sub-national to supra-national. In the same vein, the G20 could provide for closer cooperation among oceanic and inland/RTA platforms as well as hybrid RTA-oceanic alliances that may expand the possibilities for the world economy in building secure supply chains and transportation corridors. It may be then rather too early to write off the G20 as an antiquated forum of overly ambitious nation states – provided the club has the capacity to find and pursue new pathways in international economic cooperation.

Yaroslav Lissovolik, Founder, BRICS+ Analytics

Image by creativemovementglobal from Pixabay


Posted

in

,

by

Tags: